Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Human Variation vs. "Race"


1. The stress I will discuss is heat stress, given that we all (presumably) live in sunny Southern California. Heat can have a number of negative effects on human homeostasis; some of these are obvious, and others are less so. Physically, heat can affect the body temperature and hydration level of an individual, making that person susceptible to heat-related illness and death.  Heat resulting from higher exposure to the sun (or more direct equatorial sun) can increase the risk of things like skin cancer. And, heat can limit human reproductive success in other ways: if the temperature is too high, it is difficult to be outside socializing and looking for potential mates.
2. Short-term: This might include increased radiation of heat from the surface of the skin when exposed to heat stress, in order for the body to maintain a proper temperature.


Facultative adaptation: The release of certain hormones can alter the body’s metabolism in order to assist the body in maintaining an acceptable internal temperature in heated environments.


Developmental adaptations: One theory explaining the loss of body fur in hominids posits that heat stress from the African environment in which humans developed led to an evolutionary shedding of hair for improved thermoregulation. 



Cultural adaptations: Clothing styles and air conditioning might be two of the most obvious cultural adaptations to heat. In the summer, humans tend to wear less clothing, and crank the AC up in order to make the environment artificially cool.


3. Information about human variation can be very useful. By looking at variation in adaptations across clines, it is possible to see physiologically (and culturally) where, when, and why the divergent adaptations took place. Exploring the different responses to stress across time and location is beneficial for understanding how humans (and other species, for that matter) got where they are now, and perhaps where evolution might be heading in the future.
4. The idea of race implies that there are separate “species”, if you will, of humans., when in reality, there is only one species that has adapted differently to different environmental pressures. The development of humans in various geographic locations is something that can be defined and studied scientifically much more objectively than saying something like “why did different races develop”. Defining a “race” of people precisely enough to study them as a group seems doomed from the start, since there is so much variation even within groups from similar geographic areas.   

4 comments:

  1. Hi Phil,

    It's interesting how we adapt to differences in heat. I know in this weeks reading it was talking about how people in hotter climates were taller with longer limbs, which helps them to alleviate heat more quickly. I remember when my aunt was much heavier, she was hot all the time, then she lost about 150 pounds, and now she is cold more often than hot, even in the summer. I wonder what kind of change her body made to create such a difference.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Overall, very good. You have a great explanation of the stress and I liked your discussion on race.

    A couple of questions:

    Specifically, how do hormones help you adapt to heat stress? What biological changes occur because of the hormones that help you adjust to heat?

    I appreciate the reference to the arguments for hair loss in humans, but are their any other developmental changes that can happen in populations over several generations that will help them adapt to increases in heat in their environment? The hair issue is a species-level change. We are looking for population level changes.

    Images?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello Dr. Rodriguez,

      From what I understand, the thyroid produces hormones that are involved in regulating metabolism. A high metabolism means that the body maintains a higher internal temperature, whereas a low metabolic rate results in a lower core temperature. By reducing production of hormones that increase heat production in the body, internal temperature can be reduced.

      Across species, perhaps heat stress would result in a change in body type. A smaller animal with less body mass and more opportunity for surface air exposure would perform better in the heat. Sweat glands might also be one such adaptation, but I think that is also primarily human?

      I completely forgot about images. They will be posted shortly.

      :),
      Phil

      Delete
    2. Great images!

      Yes, turning down the "furnace" (our metabolism) would help with heat stress.

      Regarding body size, any suggestion on how Bergmann and Allen's rules come into play here?

      Delete